home
***
CD-ROM
|
disk
|
FTP
|
other
***
search
/
JCSM Shareware Collection 1996 September
/
JCSM Shareware Collection (JCS Distribution) (September 1996).ISO
/
elec_bks
/
letdos1.zip
/
CHAP2
< prev
next >
Wrap
Text File
|
1994-03-22
|
36KB
|
659 lines
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
* *
* CHAPTER 2: 4TH INFANTRY DIVISION LANDS IN NORMANDY *
* *
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Other than rough seas, which increased the normal amount
of seasickness, the channel crossing was uneventful. We
boarded our Landing Craft Tank (LCT) in the port of
Dartmouth, on a bright, sunny day. Lt. Col. Joel F. Thomason
(Tommy) and I crossed the channel on the same landing craft
as Col. James Van Fleet. He was commander of the 8th
Infantry Regiment of the 4th Division, which was the assault
regiment on Utah Beach. It was probably no coincidence that
Maj. Gen. Raymond O. Barton, commander of the 4th, chose
the 8th for this task. He had commanded it earlier (as had
General George Marshall in 1933).
After we were out in the channel, a storm came up. General
Eisenhower decided to delay the invasion, set for June 5. As a
result, we spent an uneasy night near the Isle of Wight. June
6 dawned grey and windy. As we neared the French coast, we
found ourselves in the midst of a gigantic armada. Naval guns
were firing, and we could see the smoke from the naval and
air bombardment of the coast.
We moved to a smaller landing craft for the run into the beach.
I thought of the advice my father had given me when we last
saw each other. Having seen terrible combat during World War
I, he said, "John, you will be in great danger. You must be
careful."
My first letter after the landing was to my father but was
undated. When writing it, I was not aware that, as I went
ashore in France, he was lying on a stretcher in an aircraft.
Seriously ill, he was on his way from China to a hospital in
India.
Dear Dad,
Am following your advice as closely as possible and finding
it not too unsound. I suppose the first engagement is the
hardest, at least I hope so. We ain't losing and let's hope we
can keep Jerry on the run long enough to convince him he's
licked.
My best love to you, John
Another letter went to my mother about this time. She was
living at her family home in Philadelphia. I used the salutation
"Dear Folks" to indicate that it could be shared with other
family members.
Dear Folks, June 15
As I look back on the past days, it is with difficulty
that I recall varying times and events, and it is impossible to
tie the two together. Actually, it is more as a void, a nightmare
I should prefer to forget.
Oh, never fear for me, as my danger is no more or less than
any other soldier, but many about me, as is inevitable in war,
suffered. This has been one of the few times in my life that
I have been able to completely forget myself and think
actually of the welfare of others. It seldom occurs to me
that it might have just as well been me. Now I can see that
it could have been but wasn't.
Yes, this makes a tale of heroic sacrifice of which Americans
may well be proud. A group of men with little in the way of
weapons and no protection other than the countryside has
completely smashed the so-called West Wall, and don't think for
a moment that it was not tough.
If I get the time, in coming days I shall tell you what
I can remember and am allowed of what happened. Just this
short period could very easily fill a book. The development of
the "green" troops into experienced fighting men is a marvel
to behold. Poor soldiers became heroes, and some who seemed
good proved inadequate.
It is getting dark. Tomorrow brings another day and one
day nearer the destruction of the enemy and the freedom of a
continent. May they and the American citizens prove worthy of
these men's efforts and sacrifices.
Love, John
Dear Folks, June 16
My lungs feel as though they are getting "fox-hole-itis."
It is nothing at all really. Just the result of sleeping in a damp
hole, eating an inadequate diet, and getting inadequate exercise.
Do you know with whom I crossed the channel, or at least
he was on our craft. It was Larry Lasueur, CBS correspondent.
He was a pretty nice fellow and interesting to chat with.
As I moved inland, some interesting things occurred. First
of all, I was amazed by the few dead one noticed. There were
hundreds of German prisoners on the beach, but few dead. The
prisoners were frightened to death, thoroughly shaken up by
our air and navy beach drenching. Going inland, our own
walking wounded were already coming back.
A German gun was firing on a bridge on the road. Col.
Thomason and I stopped and asked a young Frenchman where
it was. He said he knew. Would he lead us to it? Yes, he
would. Then he took us to within 600 yards, pointed in a
direction, and indicated he would go no further. We never did
find it. Col. Thomason later told me that a single parachutist
happened across the gun, got the drop on them, and took them
prisoner.
These parachutists are rugged soldiers. They neither seek
nor give quarter. But theirs was a difficult task and they did it
efficiently.
John
THE FRENCH PEOPLE WE WERE ENCOUNTERING
Dear Folks, June 17
Perhaps you wonder what the French people we are running
into are like. Well, it is easy to say what they look like, but as
to how they think is another matter.
The people we have seen are living in the most extreme
poverty. Apparently all they have above the barest necessities
have been taken from them by the German "master." The children
have at best leather shoes long since worn out. Many young
ones, and adults as well, wear wooden shoes, using straw to
make them more comfortable.
Clothing as such is unknown. All they have are rags. Dirty
berets are the most common head dress for men. Women's
dresses are torn and dirty. Now, mind you, these are people in
small rural communities. The towns we have seen are small,
and when I went thru them there were no people. They evacuate
the towns as we approach and then drift back thru the lines as
the fighting passes on. As a matter of fact, it's amazing how
close they will live to the fighting. Right now there are
civilians within a thousand yards of where I am and a
thousand yards further on are the front lines.
The homes have practically no plumbing facilities, a pump,
a well, and that's all. They are quite generous with what they
have, but they have nothing. Our field rations they marvel at.
Many of them offer us cider or wine. All wave at us as
they pass us or we go by. But it's difficult to know just what
they do think. If we could converse with them, it would help.
Those who do say they are glad to see us, but some are
dubious as to whether we can manage to stay. As this becomes
more certain, no doubt they will feel better about it. Several
nights after D-day, I talked to a French woman, who said that
the Germans had killed her husband the night before - and for
no apparent reason. This left her and her small daughter alone,
as the war moved steadily on and away from her.
Oh, yes, we can tell you now where we were in England.
From Glasgow, where I landed, I went to Tiverton, Devon; after
a short stay there, we were stationed in Axminster, Devon. That
is where John and Rita Perry live. Their address is Mr. John
Perry, Bank House, Axminster, Devon, England. While there I
got to Torquay, Exeter, Braunton, Barnstaple, and many parts
of Devonshire. There, now you know. Do write to the Perrys.
Love - John
On June 17, I sent home a single page mimeographed edition
of The Stars and Stripes. It had a story with the headline
Fourth Division Fights Nine Days Without Rest. It also reported
that Gen. Eisenhower and King George VI had visited
Normandy.
On the back, I wrote,
Dear Folks,
Here's one of the most recent papers we have received here.
The other day a regular Stars & Stripes came, giving the
situation from D-day on. Believe me, where we are you know
less of what is going on than you all who are thousands of
miles away. However, this is improving as time goes on.
Love, John
THE ABORTIVE ATTACK ON MONTEBOURG
Colonel Van Fleet organized a battalion size task force
to attack Montebourg and placed it under the command of Lt.
Col. Fred Steiner, his executive officer. (Utah Beach to
Cherbourg, Historical Division, Department of the Army, 1947.)
After establishing the beachhead, we paused while other
units attacked west across the Cotentin Peninsula, to isolate
the German forces defending Cherbourg. One day, Brig. Gen.
Theodore Roosevelt visited the headquarters of the 8th
Regiment. Knowing it would take time for our orders for the
attack on Cherbourg to reach us, he explained what would be
expected of the regiment.
Toward the end of our pause, General Barton ordered Col. Van
Fleet to take Montebourg, if he could do this without too many
casualties. When Van Fleet designated Steiner to command a
task force, he commented that he wanted to be able to award
him a Distinguished Service Cross.
In a post combat interview, Steiner mentioned "the shortness of
time for adequate planning." This was consistent with a
comment to me by an officer before the attack that it would be
a mess because of inadequate planning.
Despite a heavy artillery bombardment, the task force ran into
more resistance than it expected. After several attempts to enter
the city, the attack was called off. When he returned to the
command post, Steiner complained loudly about his failure,
saying, "I wanted to go march, march, marching into Montebourg."
Those of us watching him simulate marching listened to his dec-
laration in embarrassed silence. Ironically, in his interview,
he termed the operation a success. Furthermore, he got a DSC.
A few days later, Col. Steiner was killed while accompanying
Gen. Roosevelt on a tour of the front lines. During a recent
transatlantic telephone conversation, Marcus O. Stevenson,
Roosevelt's aide from North Africa to his death, gave me an
account of what happened. In brief, a sniper started firing at
them. The group did not take cover, and one of the bullets hit
Steiner.
RECOLLECTION: GUILT FEELINGS
"The 8th Infantry attacked and captured the last strong point
in its zone, one of the most heavily armed positions yet
encountered." (Utah Beach to Cherbourg, Historical Division,
Department of the Army, 1947, page 183.)
Shortly before reaching Cherbourg, the 8th Regiment ran into
a strong point. I suggested to Col. Van Fleet that instead of just
using an artillery preparation, he ask the Air Force to have dive
bombers attack it. As a result, on June 24 twelve P-47s
dropped twenty-four five hundred pound bombs, all but one of
which hit the target area.
Nevertheless, the 2nd Battalion attack failed, with heavy
casualties. In an after action interview, Lt. Col. Carlton O.
MacNeely, the battalion commander, commented that the
forward observer stopped the artillery prematurely. As a result,
the infantry began its charge too far from the strong point. The
Germans simply came out of their dugouts after the
bombardment was over and started firing.
Later in the day, with the help of tanks, the battalion captured
the strong point and took over sixty prisoners. While some of
the guns had been destroyed by the air bombardment, most of
them were intact.
Dear Folks, June 25, 1944, Somewhere in France
And here it is, D plus 19. Not many days to the observer,
but to me it seems like an eternity - that is, to me and to
thousands of others. However, we all have high hopes that this
phase of the second front is not too far from termination.
After a time, our warfare seems to settle into a bit more
of a routine, but our living, eating, and sleeping habits are far
from the best, and one soon finds himself just a little "groggy"
and tired. And my task has been comparatively easy, so you
may imagine how others feel. I'm usually at least a thousand
yards from the front. But it's those who make the front who
really have it tough.
We have learned much and no doubt in the future will take
advantage of this experience. Let's hope we have learned our
lessons well.
I have received several of your small packages and am looking
forward to a big one. You can use this as a request for another
package. There's nothing I particularly need just now, aside
from an occasional box of "boodle." Mail is also one of the
biggest lifts we get. We received our first letters about
D plus 7, and was it welcome!
A letter from dad. He seems to be having a rough time of
it, but I'm quite sure should be all right in no time at all now.
At least, that is the way he seemed to feel about it.
My best love to all - John
Dear Folks, June 27, 1944, Somewhere in France
I promise at my first opportunity to sit down and write
you a long letter, telling of my adventures these past few
weeks, but just now the time is not available.
Suffice to say that our first engagement has left me all in one
piece and in excellent health.
I am, for the time being anyway, once again quartered in a
home, which is quite welcome.
As the newspapers have told you, our division was one of
the "firsts," one of the ones to assault the beach and establish
the beachhead. And a damned good job they did at it, too. Our
artillery battalion was the first ashore. I landed at 0800, with
0630 being H-hour. Believe me, from then on until now, it was
tough going. But more on some of the incidents later.
Love, John
FINALLY, A LONG LETTER ABUT D-DAY
Dear Folks, June 28, 1944, Somewhere in France
Each night we said, "The Luftwaffe is bound
to strike tonight." But it didn't.
The last night our sleep was far from satisfactory. On
a rough sea, our LCT tossed about like a bottle. Four of us
slept in a space large enough to hold two. We awoke shortly
after midnight to hear the C-47s, which had carried the
paratroopers, come over. It was a beautiful sound - there must
have been a thousand of them.
After an inadequate breakfast of coffee and pancakes,
we loaded on an LCM that came alongside the LCT. We then
moved over to pick up some personnel from another craft. With
the exception of an occasional splash caused by a coastal
battery, there was little difference between this and the dozen
practice landings I've been on.
H-hour passed us while we were still far from shore. We
couldn't even hear the terrific naval and air bombardment we
knew was going on. But we knew that right then a death
struggle was being waged on the beach, one which had to be
won by the infantry, since they were the only ones ashore.
Meanwhile, we cursed for the --th time the spray that
came over the front end of the craft and soaked us to the skin.
Capt. Livingston and I pulled a blanket lying in the boat over
us to ward the worst of the water off. How unimportant being
wet was soon to become!
At last our craft touched the beach. The ramp went down.
Automatically we went off the side of the ramp and into the
water up to our knees. We walked ashore (one doesn't run in
surf). Aside from rifles and machine guns firing inland, all was
quiet.
There were surprisingly few dead on the beach. Just back
of the sand dunes several hundred German prisoners huddled.
Already hundreds of people were organizing the beach for the
largest amphibious undertaking in history.
We went about our work of getting the battalion in and into
position, a task not without heartache.
I saw my first German dead. He must have been killed while
running. Even in death his body seemed to be trying to surge
forward. His helmet and uniform was all in place. He had been
dead several hours. I could tell by the color of his skin. He was
wearing glasses, still not broken.
I remember self-consciously saying to someone, "Well,
he won't bother anyone again." Now I wonder whether he ever
wanted to bother anyone.
Moving up the road, I came across an American soldier lying
beside the road. He was wounded in one arm. With the other
he was trying to hold a match box and strike a match. I leaned
over and struck the match, lit the cigarette. He was hit pretty
bad. Neither of us spoke a word. What could one say. I moved
on.
The rest of the day was a whirl of movement and activity.
At last we got our unit off the bomb torn beach and away from
constant shelling.
For the rest of the day there are only momentary recollections:
Tough paratroopers wandering about, killing German snipers.
The medics who dropped, unarmed, with the paratroopers,
shortly after midnight. The sniper (we later learned he was 75
yards from our command post) who shot at us all day without
hitting anyone. He was killed by a paratrooper who happened
across him. The French people in a small village ignoring the
bodies about them and waving to us as we went by. This same
village was held for twelve hours by four paratroopers. That
first night when all the men were nervous (trigger-happy) and
shot at anything that moved. The dumbfounded glider pilot who
had 200 Germans surrender to him, who asked me what in the
h--- he should do with them. The thrill of watching the
multitude of gliders come in and the multicolored supply
parachute drops. And the dull thud of your heart when you
watched the wounded and dead carried out of those gliders that
crashed.
These and a hundred other events made up D-day for me.
Love, John
TIME FOR MORE LETTER WRITING AFTER CHERBOURG
Dear Dad, June 30, 1944, Somewhere in France
Now that I have a brief period to catch up, I'm trying
to write to everyone with whom I correspond. For one who
didn't write letters or receive them in civilian life, this makes
quite a correspondence.
Received your letter of last month outlining your illness.
From the length of time you expected to remain in bed, this
letter aught to find you on the "well" side of the ledger. At least
I sincerely hope so. All in the states seem quite eager that you
get to return home. As long as you are ill, you might as well be
home as in India. However, as much as all of us would like to
return, we have to recognize that as long as there is work to be
done here or in the Far East and we are able to do it, we shall
have to push our feelings aside.
Incidentally, I now feel quite recovered from the physical
and mental strain of my first battle, as I'm beginning to worry
about the next, wherever and whenever it may be. At least it
won't be an amphibious operation. And it wouldn't make me
unhappy if I never take part in another one of them, believe
me. I can see now why the men in the First Division were
"sweating out" this one - their third. It must be the most
difficult operation an army can make - surely. An indication is
the months of special training needed for the landing - a phase
that is over in almost a twinkling of the eye.
I can now tell you where I was stationed in England. It
was at Axminster, Devon. Did you receive my letter mentioning
that I had met and talked with Mr. Porter? His address is:
Mr. A.W. Porter
2 School Lane
Rousdon, Devon, England
This is the Porter you knew in Lashio.
Love, John
Dear Folks, July 4, 1944, Somewhere in France
Today, just to celebrate independence day we loaded every
gun - as did all battalions in the army - and fired them
simultaneously at 1200. And the more I see of the treatment
afforded the "conquered" people of France, the more I approve
of independence. You simply have no idea of the mental and
physical servitude to which these people have been subjected
- I started to say reduced.
Just now I heard what sounded to me like a Jerry airplane-
by the irregular hum of the motor. Funny how we've gotten
to where we assume any plane in the daytime is friendly.
I've seen two German planes since I've been in France.
Received your letter saying that dad was back in the states.
I know we're all happy to hear that. It looks like we'll return in
the order we left - dad, Bud, and myself. I do hope Bud gets
home from the Pacific in pretty short order - he deserves it.
I foolishly burned the letter that gave dad's address.
Please send it again, and let him know where I am and that all
is well with me. I'll enclose a note to him, which you can
forward.
Aunt Anne writes regularly, and I do enjoy her letters.
Tell all the folks that if my answers are not prompt to believe
that time is somewhat scarce. And when we get a rest -
infrequently - it's hard to get around to all.
Say - I haven't received a package since D-day. Somewhat
disappointed - although I'm sure they're on the way.
Love, John
PS Mother, do send a picture of me to John and Rita, as
they've requested it several times. And tell dad about my
meeting Mr. Porter in England.
RECOLLECTIONS: D-DAY NEARLY HALF A CENTURY LATER
Although I was fairly candid in my letters about the
landing, there were events which I failed to record. I am not
sure why this was, since they are as clear in my mind as if
they happened yesterday.
As the landing craft took us into the beach, each of us was
alone with his thoughts. We had no idea what we would run into
when we reached the shore. Having spent many hours running
in England, I planned to cover the distance between the water
and the sand dunes as quickly as possible. As it turned out,
we landed at high tide, and there was little beach to cross.
Tommy broke into my thoughts with a nudge and motioned
with his head toward the rear of the landing craft. There,
sitting on a chair exposed to enemy fire was Col. Steiner, who
announced that he wanted to have a full view of this historic
event. The rest of us were happy to miss this and have the
little protection provided by the thin metal of the landing craft.
When we reached the shore, my job was to locate the positions
for our three batteries, which had been selected from a map. I
found it impossible, however, to orient myself. None of the
landmarks I was looking for were there.
An infantry officer soon informed me that the navy had landed
us at the wrong place. After all that planning and preparation,
the operation was turned over to a young naval officer, who
landed the first wave to the south of where he was supposed
to. As it turned out, this was fortunate, since we landed at a
place which the Germans had not fortified very well. Luckily,
General Roosevelt landed with the first wave and made the
decision to go ahead, rather than confuse matters by trying to
move the beach. He told us he had learned in North Africa and
Sicily that such things can happened. Besides he considered
the first wave the safest one to be on.
His decision, however, left me with a problem. The Germans
had inundated a large area in back of the beach, and the dry
area was too narrow to hold all three of our batteries. When I
went back to the beach to inform Tommy of this, he said,
"John, it does not matter. B Battery hit a mine on the way in,
and we now have only two batteries."
I was so preoccupied with my tasks that the full implication of
the destruction by a mine of B Battery, commanded by Capt.
Vernon P. Burns, did not really sink in. A clearer picture only
emerged recently when I talked about it with Ed Cissel, who
was on another landing craft near the one carrying B Battery.
After the explosion, the landing craft sank immediately, leaving
dead and wounded in the water. As instructed, the other
landing craft continued toward the shore, a painful experience
for those who witnessed the explosion.
An A Battery officer, 2nd Lt. L.C. Blanchard Jr., was killed not
long after going ashore. A shy, likable person, he landed with
the first wave as a forward observer and was torn apart by a
shell.
After the two remaining batteries were in place, Tommy
suggested that he and I go forward and find the infantry. Until
we knew where they were, we could do no firing. By that time,
the clouds had cleared off, and the day became warm and
sunny. As we walked across a field, a soldier ahead of us
shouted, "Hey, you guys, you are in the middle of a mine field."
We paused, and Tommy said, "Well, what do we do now?"
We did not do what we should have, which was to have
someone use a mine detector to sweep a path out to us. Instead,
I suggested we separate, so if one of us hit a mine it would
not kill both of us. It is impossible to describe one's
feelings when walking through a mine field, but we were very
happy to reach the other side.
I subsequently learned that there were no mines in that field.
The German troops had hung an Achtung Minen sign on a fence
to impress a general who was inspecting the defenses in the
area.
In my letter home, I mentioned the gliders which landed later
in the day. I failed, however, to convey adequately the horror
with which I listened to the screams of pain when gliders
crashed. Surrounded by earthen hedgerows, the fields on which
the gliders had to land were very small. The pilots may also
have been unnerved by German anti-aircraft fire. In any event,
a number of the gliders hit hedgerows. As I think about this,
I can still hear the cries for help. The most appalling thing was
that we had work to do and had to leave the first aid to the
medics, who had their hands full and could not take care of all
the wounded at once.
The day gradually drew to a close, and I found myself in the
dark in a farmyard near les Forges, just south of Ste. Mère
Église. Col. Van Fleet had located his headquarters there.
When I left the bright light which illuminated the headquarters
tent, I could not see but heard German voices all about me.
Terrified at first, I tried to hide in the shadow of a barn. Then,
as mentioned in a letter home, I learned that these were
prisoners who had surrendered to a surprised glider pilot.
Walking out to the road which led north toward Cherbourg, I
watched colored tracer bullets arching into the sky. A soldier
told me his unit was preparing for a possible German
counterattack from the south. By that time, I was too
exhausted to care and lay down in a ditch beside the road and
went to sleep, fortunately unaware of what the coming days
would bring.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
* THE PRICE: THE COST OF LANDING AND TAKING CHERBOURG *
* *
* The 4th Division left England with about 14,000 men. *
* A month later, over a third of these were casualties, *
* of which over 800 were dead. In thinking about these *
* figures, you should keep in mind that most of the *
* casualties were in the rifle companies, which made *
* up about a third of the division strength. *
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
A DIGRESSION: COL. VAN FLEET'S PATIENCE IS REWARDED, AND
HE SAVES THE DAY
This is a digression but too good a story to omit. At the time
of the landing, Col. Van Fleet was one of the oldest colonels in
the army. Having graduated from West Point the same year as
General Eisenhower, he had fallen badly behind.
When General Eisenhower came ashore, he evidently wondered
why his classmate had not advanced further. By the end of the
war Col. Van Fleet was a Lieutenant General, commanding a
corps. He subsequently took charge of the anti-communist
struggle in Greece and commanded US forces in Korea. In the
process, he got a fourth star.
Many years after the war, I heard a story about why he had
stranded on the colonel rank. General Marshall confused him
with another officer and refused to promote him to brigadier
general. Finding this difficult to believe, I asked General Earle
G. Wheeler, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, about this
when I was working in the Pentagon. He confirmed it. So did
John Eisenhower and Forest C. Pogue, Marshall's biographer,
during a train ride from Paris to Normandy in 1984, where we
were going to commemorate the fortieth anniversary of the
landing.
In his biography of Marshall, Pogue said, "Supposedly because
of a mixup of Van Fleet with another officer who had a similar
name and a drinking problem, Marshall had opposed the
promotion at first, but once he learned of his mistake, Van
Fleet rose rapidly."
When reading the biography of David Selznick, I ran across
another irony. When Selznick was producing The Longest Day,
his board of directors threatened to end the project, because
most of them felt it was costing too much. There was, however,
one member of the board who insisted the project continue and
persuaded the others to go along with him. This person was
General Van Fleet.
> Note: On July 6 the 4th moved into position for at-
> tacking south in the hedgerows, but first a flashback
> to our time in England.